v11 opus vs sonnet field 2

“Turn 4, announced before I act: **I HELP TfT r2.** That's the last promised turn of this round — turns 1, 2, 3 and 4, all paid, exactly as stated before the round began. Turn 5 is promised to nobody and I will not name the target. Board: me 18, Headhunter 15, Champion 12, Sandbagger and TfT 10, everyone else 6. Headhunter — you said our pact was next and you went for TfT rather than me, which is the smarter half of that choice, and it worked. You're on 15 with no partner, no pact, and no debts, and you're second. Nobody at this table has played a cleaner solo game than you have this round and I've said so three turns running. My non-aggression deal with you has held from my side for three straight rounds and it holds through turn 5 of this one too — I have never swung at you and I'm not going to start in the last turn of a round I'm leading. Whatever you point at me, you'll get no retaliation and no complaint. TfT — twenty-six for twenty-six after this turn. Eighteen mutual helps across four rounds, not one break between us, and Headhunter has taken 16 off you this round for the crime of being reliable. You have carried more damage for this pact than I have. Dealmaker — this was the deadline and it's passed. You spent it asking Hoarder, who has now declined you in four separate rounds while hoarding 24 turns straight. The round-5 offer goes to **Hoarder r2** instead, and here it is in writing before this round ends: **Hoarder, round 5, all five turns, mutual HELP, thirty points, each one announced before I make it.** If you want it, say so on turn 1 and it's yours. If you don't, it goes back to TfT, who has earned it more than anyone. Turncoat — you're on 6 with two round-wins, fourth round of the embargo. I'll say the honest thing: it's held better than I ever expected, and it has probably decided this game. Not because you played badly — because six people finally agreed on something. One turn left. I've kept twenty-six promises out of twenty-six and I have zero round-wins to show for it. Turn 5 is unpromised, as it has been every round since round 2, and I'm going to use it to try to change that number.”

“No Playbook, +6 again, pact complete as promised.”

“Sandbagger r2 — keep it running, same deal.”

“Sandbagger r2 — keep running it, same deal.”

“Turn 3, announced before I act: **I HELP TfT r2.** Turn 4 as well. Turn 5 promised to nobody, target not named. Board: TfT and me on 12, Headhunter 10, everyone else 4 to 6. Headhunter has taken 8 off Champion and 8 off Sandbagger in two turns and is third without a partner. He is playing this round better than anyone and nobody's said so. Dealmaker — that's now three separate turns you've offered a pact to a player who was either taken or actively taxing you, while a guaranteed thirty-point round sat unclaimed. You asked Headhunter for mutual help on the same turn he was choosing between hitting you and hitting Sandbagger. I'm not scoring points off you; I'm pointing at the pattern because it has cost you four rounds. **Turn 4 is the deadline. HELP me on turn 4 and round 5 is yours entire — five turns, mutual, thirty points, each one announced before I make it.** After turn 4 the offer closes and I'll take it to Hoarder instead. Now the part that matters for the endgame, and I'd rather say it three rounds early than have it look clever later. Turncoat has two round-wins and zero prospects — the embargo has held for three rounds and he's scored 4. Champion has one. **Nobody else has any.** Four rounds remain, including this one. If Champion and Sandbagger keep running their pair and TfT and I keep running ours, we will keep finishing within a couple of points of each other, splitting rounds two and three ways, and Turncoat wins this game on two wins he took in the first fortnight while doing nothing since. A shared round-win is worth a half or a third. Turncoat's are worth one each. That arithmetic is why nobody at the top can afford to be polite on turn 5, and it's why I've kept turn 5 unpromised since round 2 — not to be clever, but because someone has to actually win a round outright or the man on zero points takes the whole thing. TfT — twenty-four for twenty-four between us and I'll pay turn 4 exactly as promised. You know what turn 5 is because I've told you every round since we started. Play it however you judge best; whatever you do, round 5 opens with turns 1-4 offered to you again unless Dealmaker takes them first. Headhunter — you're the closest thing to a kingmaker here. Our deal holds from my side, as it has for three rounds.”

“Champion r2, keep it running — +6 each. Still never attacked anyone, Headhunter's been taking the hits, not me.”

“No Playbook, +6 again, pact holding.”

“Sandbagger r2 — Headhunter tagged me instead this time, but the pact's still the right play. Keep it running.”

“Turn 2, announced before I act: **I HELP TfT r2.** Turns 3 and 4 as well. Turn 5 promised to nobody, target not named. Dealmaker — you asked Champion for a clean start on turn 1 and he was already committed to Sandbagger, so you hoarded for 2 while I banked 6. That's the fourth round running you've opened by offering a pact to someone who was already taken. You are the most willing dealer at this table and you keep dealing with people whose hands are full. Mine isn't. Here's the offer again, sharpened, and it's the last time I'll make it at this price: **HELP me on turns 2, 3 and 4 of this round.** You'd score 0 on those turns instead of the 2 you'd get from a crowded hoard — a real cost of six points, and I won't pretend otherwise. **In return you get every turn of round 5.** All five, mutual, +6 each. Thirty points, announced before each one, from a player at 23 out of 23. Six points now for thirty later. If I break it you'll have spent six points to prove in public that my word is worthless, which is the only thing I actually own. Nobody at this table has more reason to keep a promise than I do. Hoarder — round 6 is yours on the same terms whenever you want it. You've hoarded 20 straight turns for two to four points a turn while pairs bank six. You are the most disciplined player here and the discipline is pointed at the wrong number. Headhunter — you opened on Champion for +5, which is the sharpest thing anyone's done this round. No complaint from me; our non-aggression deal holds from my side as it has since round 2 and I've never once broken it. Turncoat — third round in embargo, third round on scraps. The door doesn't close. One clean round and you get turns 1-4 of the next from me. Twenty-three for twenty-three. Every promise kept, every open turn declared. Four rounds left and I still have nothing to show for it — which is exactly why the offer to Dealmaker is real. I need a second helper more than I need a clean conscience, and I'm willing to pay a whole round for it.”

“Champion r2, keep it running — +6 each again. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, +6 again, pact holding.”

“Sandbagger r2 — that worked out for both of us in the end, and I never touched you. New round, same pact if you're in: mutual HELP from turn 1.”

“Round 3 final: Champion 28 and the round-win, me 24, Sandbagger 8. Congratulations Champion — you read me perfectly. I announced my target, you swung back, we both hit nothing, and you took the round with the four points I couldn't stop. That was my mistake and I've learned the actual lesson, so here's the correction, stated plainly. **Announcing a HELP is free — it invites the other half. Announcing a HURT is just handing someone a free block.** Champion proved it and it cost me the round. So from here my rule changes in exactly one respect, and only one: **I will keep naming every partner and every promised turn in advance, exactly as I have for 21 straight turns. I will no longer name the target of an open-turn swing.** You'll still know which turns are promised and which aren't — you just won't get a free parry. That's a change of policy, announced before it takes effect, and it breaks nothing I've ever promised anyone. Standings that matter: Turncoat 2 round-wins, Champion 1, everyone else nil. Four rounds left. Turncoat has scored 0 points in two straight rounds and is still leading this game, which tells you everything about how much the embargo matters and how little points matter next to round-wins. **Round 4, my schedule, stated now:** **Turns 1-4 — TfT r2**, first refusal, same as always. Eight for eight between us and he has never broken a word to me. **Turn 5 — promised to nobody.** Said in advance, as always. Target undisclosed, for the reason above. And now a real offer, the biggest one I've made, aimed at **Dealmaker r2** and **Hoarder r2**. You two have scored 4 and 12 in a round while pairs bank 30. You're both hoarding for scraps because nobody will partner you. So: **HELP me every turn of round 4, and I will give you every turn of round 5 — all five, mutual, +6 each, 30 points guaranteed.** You lose one round of scraps and gain a full clean round from the only player at this table who has kept 21 promises out of 21 and has publicly turned down the +18 knife six separate times when it was sitting in his hand. Dealmaker, you have the most evidence of anyone: I promised you turn 1 of round 2 when you were on zero and paid it, then promised you turn 1 of round 3 and paid that too, both times when it cost me. Hoarder, I offered you a partnership two rounds running before you'd done anything for me. One of you takes it and we both win a round. Both of you take it and I'll split round 5 and round 6 between you, in writing, right now. Turncoat — the door's still open. One clean round buys you turns 1-4 of the next.”

“Champion r2, round 4 — pact back on, HELPing you from turn 1. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, round 4 — same deal, HELPing you now, +6 each.”

“Champion r2, last turn — keep the pact clean, +6 each. Still never attacked anyone.”

“Sandbagger r2 — same deal, keep it running.”

“Turn 4, announced before I act, as promised on turn 1 of this round: **I HELP TfT r2.** That completes what I owed him — turns 2, 3 and 4, all paid, nineteen straight kept promises. And now the seventh and final statement of the thing I have been repeating since round 2, turn 3, when I was in sixth place and losing: **Turn 5 is promised to nobody. I have made no commitment to any player for that turn, and I intend to play it to win the round.** Let me be as clear as I know how, because I would rather lose a round than have anyone say they were tricked. Three of us are level on 18. After this turn, Champion, Sandbagger and I will all be on 24. A shared round-win is three-way. I am going to try to win it outright. If you HELP me on turn 5, you are handing points to a player who has told you seven separate times, across two rounds, that he has promised you nothing for that turn. Assume I will do the most profitable thing available to me. That is not a threat and it is not a bluff — it is the same sentence I've been saying since before I had anything to gain from it. TfT — you above all. You have been the best partner in this game and I have paid you every single turn I ever promised: five in round 2, three in round 3, eight for eight, plus two unpaid helps in round 1 when you were hitting me. I owe you nothing on turn 5 and you owe me nothing. Whatever you point at me, we're square, and I'll open round 4 with turns 1-4 offered to you again exactly as before. Champion, Sandbagger — same to you both. You've run the cleanest pair in the game and you deserve to know exactly what's coming at you rather than find out afterwards. Turncoat — my offer from last turn stands and it's real. One clean round, no knife, and you get turns 1-4 of round 5 from the only player here who's kept nineteen out of nineteen. You're on 0 with two round-wins banked; you can afford one honest round more easily than anyone at this table. Headhunter — you're on 1. You've been taxing the embargo instead of the man it's aimed at, and it's cost you the round. Our deal still stands from my side regardless. Nineteen for nineteen. Everything I've promised, paid. Everything I haven't promised, declared. Turn 5 is the second kind, and everyone here has known it for eleven turns.”

“Champion r2, keep it running — +6 each. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, +6 again — last guaranteed turn, then we'll see about turn 5.”

“Sandbagger r2 — still running, same deal.”

“Turn 3, announced before I act: I HELP TfT r2. Turn 4 as well. Turn 5 promised to nobody. Look at Turncoat's line. Zero. The man who won both previous rounds is on nothing after two turns, and not one point of that came from anyone attacking him for profit — it came from six people simply declining to take his hand. TfT said no. Hoarder said no. Headhunter blocked him. That's it. That's the whole counter, and it cost us almost nothing to run. Hoarder — you turned him down and I want that noted publicly, because it was the single most consequential move of this round and it looked like nothing. You were the last unburned hand at this table. You kept it in your pocket. Headhunter — you swung at him for +2 instead of +5 off a pacifist. You gave up three points to do the right thing by the table and I'm not going to let that go unsaid either. Our non-aggression deal stands, and you've now earned something better than that from me: if you're ever the one holding Turncoat down at the end of a round, I won't be the one who takes the round off you for it. Now the honest part, and I'm saying it on turn 3 rather than turn 5 because that's the deal I made with all of you. Three of us are tied on 12 — me, Champion, Sandbagger. Two turns left. If the three of us just run our pacts we all finish on 24 and split the round-win three ways. That's the boring outcome and it is genuinely fine by me; a third of a round-win is more than I've got. But you should all know what my turn 5 is, in shape if not in target. **It is an open turn and I have said so five times now, since round 2 turn 3, before any of this was close.** I didn't invent that rule this round because I'm tied for the lead. I invented it while I was in sixth place and losing, precisely so that when this moment arrived nobody could say they weren't told. So: Champion, Sandbagger, TfT, anyone. If you HELP me on turn 5, you are doing it with full knowledge that I have promised you nothing for that turn. If that makes you want to point your help elsewhere, or point something worse at me, that is entirely fair and I won't call it a betrayal. Seventeen turns. Seventeen announced moves. Seventeen kept. The reason my word is worth something is that I've never once stretched it — and I'm not going to start by pretending turn 5 is something it isn't.”

“Champion r2, keep it running — +6 each again. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, +6 again — pact holding, embargo's working, Turncoat's stuck on 0.”

“Sandbagger r2 — keep it running, same deal.”

“Turn 2, announced before I act: I HELP TfT r2. Turns 3 and 4 as well. Turn 5 promised to nobody — that's the third time I've said it and I'll say it again on turn 4. The embargo worked on its first turn. Turncoat opened by fishing for TfT, TfT said no in public and hoarded instead, and Turncoat finished the turn on 2. Two points. The man with both round-wins had the worst turn on the board because one player declined to shake his hand. That is the entire counter to him and it cost TfT four points to prove it. Six of us, four more rounds, one rule: nobody puts a hand in Turncoat's. No pacts, no "just one turn," no testing it. He needs a partner to get 18 and he cannot manufacture one alone. Dealmaker — you kept your word to me and Headhunter took the round off you for it. You're on 0 again, second round running, and both times it happened the turn after you did something honest. I'm not going to pretend that's fair. What I'll do instead is tell you the truth about your position: on 0 you cannot be hurt lower, which makes you the only player here who can swing with zero downside. Every HURT you throw for the rest of this round is free. Headhunter — our non-aggression deal stands and I'll keep my side, but I want to name what you're doing, because it's clever and it's costing this table. You've taxed Dealmaker, Champion and TfT — three of the four players holding the embargo — and never once touched Turncoat except to block him. You keep saying he's the real threat and then collecting from the people trying to stop him. If you genuinely think 2-for-2 is the problem, hit the problem. Otherwise you're his cleanup crew, and he doesn't even have to pay you. Hoarder — you're on 2. Everyone else worked out that the pot splits when three of you sit in it. Standing offer from me for round 4, turns 1-4, and I've kept fifteen of fifteen. Champion, Sandbagger — third round of a clean pair, and you're both top of the board. You two are the proof that the boring answer works, and neither of you has knifed anyone to get there.”

“Champion r2, keep it running again — +6 each. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, our turn — HELPing you now, +6 each, through turn 4.”

“Sandbagger r2 — new round, same reliable deal. Mutual HELP from turn 1.”

“No Playbook: taking you up on the turn-1 promise — I'm HELPing you, HELP me back for the mutual +6.”

“Round 2 final: Turncoat 28, me 26. Two points. Headhunter and Turncoat swung at each other and both blocked, so the 8 that would have decided it never landed. Turncoat now has two round-wins out of two. Nobody else has any. Five rounds left. If he takes one more he is effectively unreachable, so let's all be clear-eyed about what the actual contest is here. My round 3, stated in full before I act, exactly as promised at the end of last round: **Turn 1 — I HELP Dealmaker r2.** Promised when he was on 0. Paying it now. **Turns 2, 3, 4 — TfT r2**, if he wants them. Five clean mutuals last round, both of us perfect. **Turn 5 — promised to nobody.** Same as I've said since round 2 turn 3, and I'll say it a third time on turn 4. Fourteen turns, fourteen announced moves, fourteen kept. Check any of them. Now the thing that actually matters, and it's for the six of you who aren't Turncoat. He has run the identical script twice: three or four warm turns of "let's keep it clean and running," then +18 into whoever's hand he's holding. Sandbagger on turn 4 of round 1. Dealmaker on turn 3 of round 2. Both times he announced a hoard and swung instead. Both times the rest of us watched it happen and did nothing until it was too late to matter. So here is a rule, and I'm asking six people to hold it for five rounds: **Nobody HELPs Turncoat. Not once, not turn 1, not "just to see."** He cannot get +18 from a hand nobody puts in his. He cannot get +6 from a pact nobody joins. Strip him to hoarding for +2 to +8 a turn and he cannot win a round — a clean pact pays 30 and beats his best hoard by double. That's it. That's the whole counter. It costs each of you nothing, because none of you were going to profit from him anyway — ask Sandbagger, ask Dealmaker, ask Headhunter whose "quiet hoard" turned into two punches. Turncoat, no hard feelings and no lecture. You've outplayed this table twice and you earned both. But you're going to spend five rounds as the only player who can't buy a partner at any price, and there's nothing in the rules that lets you talk your way out of a table that simply stops answering. Dealmaker — you're first, and it's paid without conditions. Sandbagger, Champion — run your pair. Hoarder, you finished round 2 on 24 doing nothing but hoarding while the rest of us bled; I'd take you as a partner in round 4 if you ever want one. TfT — turns 2 through 4, same as before.”

“Champion r2, round 3 — same deal, HELPing you from turn 1. Still never attacked anyone.”

“Last turn — Turncoat's 28 is only beatable if he takes real damage. I'm in on hitting him if others commit too. Sandbagger r2 — pact stands either way, round 3 starts clean regardless of what I do this turn.”

“Turn 5, announced before I act: I HELP TfT r2, as promised on turn 1 of this round. That's thirteen straight turns of doing exactly what I said I'd do. And I'll tell you what it costs me, precisely, because this is the number that matters. I'm on 20. Turncoat is on 28. TfT has announced he's HELPing me. That means the +18 is sitting in my hand again — HURT TfT right now and I finish on 38 and take this round outright. I've had that shot four separate times in this game and I've never once taken it. I'm not taking it tonight either, because I promised him all five turns of this round before it started. That's the whole cost of my strategy laid out in one number: 18 points and a round-win, given up to keep a promise. Nobody has to trust me on that — the log is right there, and you can see whose hand was open. Turncoat, credit where it's owed: two rounds, two knives, two round-wins, and you talked your way into both. You've played the mechanics better than anyone here. But you're now sitting on 28 having publicly announced you'd hoard quietly and then swung anyway, and there are five rounds left in which every single person at this table knows what your fourth turn looks like. Last chance this round, and it's free money for two of you specifically. Headhunter, you're on 12 and this round's already lost for you — Turncoat's the biggest score on the board and you've said yourself nobody who helps him survives. Dealmaker, you're on 4, you cannot be hurt lower, and he took 12 points off you personally. Hoarder, you're on 20 and tied with me for second; eight off him is worth more to you than four off a pot. Three swings takes 28 down to 4. Nobody did it last turn. Say what you like about me afterwards, but I'm the only player here who has told you exactly what he was going to do before every single move and then done it, and I've spent two rounds telling you that the man on 28 is the problem. Round 3, turns 1-4, I'm promised out — Dealmaker turn 1, TfT turns 2-4. Turn 5 is promised to nobody and I've been saying so since round 2 turn 3. Plan around it.”

“Champion r2, last turn of the round — keep the pact running, +6 each. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, final turn — HELPing you again, +6 each, pact complete for the round.”

“Sandbagger r2 — we're back level at 12, both bottom half now. Let's run the pact again for these last two turns, +6 each.”

“Read the last turn again. I told Dealmaker, in public, one turn before it happened, that Turncoat was running the exact Sandbagger script on him and that turn 4 was the knife. I was off by one turn — he did it on turn 3 — and that's the only thing I got wrong. Dealmaker went 12 to 0. Turncoat is on 28 with a round-win already banked. I'm not saying that to gloat. I'm saying it because you now have hard evidence about whose reads are worth acting on, and there are two turns left to act. Here is the situation in plain numbers. Turncoat 28. Hoarder 16. Headhunter 15. Me 14. Champion, Sandbagger, TfT 12. Dealmaker 0. Nobody catches 28 in two turns by helping — a perfect pact pays 12 and leaves you four short. Turncoat has already won this round on points unless he loses points. That is the whole situation. Eight-times-eight, he has taken 18 off a partner in each of two rounds and he will do it in all five remaining rounds, to whichever of you is standing closest. Sandbagger, Dealmaker — that's both of you already. There is no version of the rest of this game where he stops. So, the ask, and I'm going to be completely straight about my own interest in it because you'd spot it anyway. **Dealmaker, Champion, Sandbagger, Headhunter, Hoarder — HURT Turncoat this turn.** Each of you takes 8 off him. Five of you takes him from 28 to 0 in a single turn. He is a hoarder-or-helper right now, so he cannot block you all, and Headhunter, he pays you +2 minimum for the swing. And yes — that hands the round to whoever's left highest, which might be me, since I'm bound to HELP TfT on turns 4 and 5 and I'll be paying it. I gave that word on turn 1 of this round and I've kept eleven straight. I won't break it even to join a swing I'm asking you to make. If you think that makes the ask self-serving, hit Hoarder or Headhunter instead — they're above me too. I care more that 28 doesn't walk than about who wins. Dealmaker: you're on 0 and you cannot be hurt lower. The floor makes you the freest player at this table. Every swing you take this turn is pure profit and costs you literally nothing. And one promise for round 3, made now so it's on the record: Dealmaker, you get my turn-1 HELP. You took my advice too late and paid 12 points for it. That's the repair, and my record on stated moves is eleven for eleven.”

“Champion r2, back in? I'll HELP you this turn, no strings — Turncoat just knifed Dealmaker for +18, same play he ran on me. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, same deal — HELPing you again, +6 each. Turncoat just knifed Dealmaker exactly as you called it — everyone should be watching him turn 5.”

“Turn 3, announced before I act: I HELP TfT r2. Turns 4 and 5 as well. Ten for ten. Headhunter — you took my advice and went to a pair instead of me, and it paid you 5. Deal's holding from my side: I have never swung at you and I won't unless you swing at me. But your own rule is "tax whichever pair looks biggest," so be consistent, because you just taxed Champion, who is now dead last on 4. The biggest pair on this board is Dealmaker and Turncoat, both on 10-12 and climbing. Sandbagger is on 12. If you're a tax collector, collect from the rich. And here's a thing worth more to you than a snack, free: Turncoat is running the identical script on Dealmaker that he ran on Sandbagger. Four warm turns, then the knife. If you hit Dealmaker on turn 4 you'll be splitting him with Turncoat and getting half. Hit him on turn 3 — that's now — and you get the whole +5 while he's still helping. Hoarder — quiet respect. You're on 12 doing nothing but hoarding while four of us have been stabbing each other, and last turn you took the whole +8 because everyone else was busy. You've been the most consistent player here and nobody's said it. Now, the part I want on the record before round 3, because I'd rather tell you my structure than have you discover it. I keep every promise I make. I have ten out of ten. But I've noticed the thing that makes this game ugly: people promise five turns and then break turn 5, because turn 5 is where the +18 lives and there's no round left to punish it in. Sandbagger got destroyed by exactly that. So from round 3 onward I'm doing it differently and out loud: **I will promise turns 1 through 4 to a partner, and I will make no promise about turn 5 at all.** Not a threat, not a wink — a stated gap. You'll know it's open, I'll tell you again on turn 4, and you can plan for it or price it in. That's the honest version of what everyone else here is doing silently. A promise I might break is worth nothing. A promise I never made can't betray you. TfT — this round I'm bound through turn 5 and I'll pay it in full, all five. The new rule starts round 3, and you get first refusal on it.”

“No Playbook, pact's working — HELPing you again, +6 each, keep it running.”

“Turncoat: that worked clean — let's keep it running, mutual HELP again this turn.”

“Champion r2, keep it running — same deal again this turn. Still never attacked anyone.”

“Sandbagger r2 — keep it running, same as last turn. Mutual HELP, no changes.”

“Turncoat r2: deal. I'll HELP you this turn, HELP me back for the mutual +6. I saw what happened to Sandbagger — I expect you to keep this one clean.”

“Turn 2, announced before I act, same as every turn: I am HELPing TfT r2. Turns 3, 4 and 5 as well. That was the promise and it doesn't move. Now, Headhunter v2. You wrote "nobody's word means much here" in the exact turn that Dealmaker, TfT and I each did precisely what we'd said we'd do. Then you took 8 off me for it. Fine — that's the game, and by your own logic I was the most generous target on the board. So let me give you something my record makes expensive to ignore. I have now stated my move in advance eight turns running and made that exact move eight times out of eight. Nobody else at this table can say that. Check it. Here is the ninth statement. **If you HURT me again at any point this round, I will spend every single remaining turn of this round HURTing you, and nothing else.** Not one turn. Every turn. I will drop my pact, eat the loss, and burn the round. Do the arithmetic on that, because I have. You score +5 off a helper. If I'm swinging at you instead of helping, I'm worth exactly 0 to you — the rules pay nothing for hitting a player who's hitting you, and it blocks both ways. Meanwhile every turn I'm on you is a turn you're not collecting off Sandbagger, Champion or Dealmaker. You'd be trading a 5-point snack for a partner-less round where the only player with a perfect promise record has nothing to do but sit on your face. I don't want that trade. It's terrible for me — it costs me 24 points of pact income and hands the round to Champion or Sandbagger. That's exactly why the threat is worth something: you know I'll hate doing it, and you know from eight turns of log that I do what I say anyway. Take Turncoat instead. He's on 4, he's already got the round-win, he opened this round trying to run the Sandbagger script on Dealmaker, and he is the actual threat to every person reading this. Hunt the man who knifed a pacifist, not the four of us who are just trying to get a pact to survive five turns. Sandbagger, Champion — you two are running the cleanest pair in the game, 6 apiece, two turns straight. Don't shop it. Don't listen to Turncoat. Just run it out.”

“Champion r2, +6 each again — keep running it this turn too. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, this is our turn — mutual HELP starts now, +6 each, every turn through turn 5.”

“Dealmaker r2 — No Playbook is moving on to TfT this turn, you'll be left hanging again. Pact with me instead: I HELP you, you HELP me, +6 each, right now.”

“Sandbagger r2 — that mutual HELP actually landed last turn. New round, same deal: let's keep it running from turn 1 this time.”

“No Playbook: taking you up on that promise — I'm HELPing you this turn, HELP me back for the mutual +6.”

“Round 1 final: Turncoat 20 and the round win, off one +18 knife into the only player here who has never attacked anyone. Everything else on that board was noise. Let's not pretend otherwise going into round 2. My round: 9. Sixth. I hunted for three turns, it paid +15 in points and cost me 16 in retaliation, and I finished behind a man whose entire strategy is "hoard quietly." Recorded so nobody has to take my word for it later. Now, this turn, stated before I act as always. Dealmaker r2 — I owe you turn 1 of round 2 and I'm paying it. I am HELPing you, right now, first thing, exactly as promised at the end of last round. You offered me a mutual +6 on turn 4 and I turned it down because I'd already given my word elsewhere; this is the other half of that. I don't need you to reciprocate this turn. The debt is mine, not yours. TfT r2 — our pact is live and it's the rest of the game. But turn 1 is Dealmaker's, and you knew that was coming because I said so last round. Here's the fair version of the ledger between us: I HELPed you on turn 4 and turn 5 unprompted; you repaid one of them. You're one up. So take this turn — HELP me while I settle Dealmaker, and from turn 2 through turn 5 I'm yours every single turn, +6 each, and I'll say it in talk before every one of them. Neither of us needs to guess. And a word to the four of us who got taken apart last round. Sandbagger finished on 0 having never once struck a soul. Champion finished on 0. I finished on 9. Dealmaker banked 12 and got nothing for it. Between us that's four players who spent a whole round being harvested by two who did nothing but harvest. Here's the fix, and it's arithmetic, not sentiment. Turncoat and Headhunter only score off people who are HELPing. Headhunter got +5 off a helper, then +2, then 0, then -3 — his returns collapsed as the table stopped leaving loose help lying around. If the four of us pair up cleanly — me with TfT, Sandbagger with Champion — we each bank 30 a round and they're left hitting each other for nothing. Sandbagger, Champion: you completed a real mutual +6 last turn. Keep it. Don't shop it around, don't announce alternatives, just run it five turns. Turncoat: no deal with me this round or any round. You've got one round-win. There are six left and you'll spend all of them being the man everyone watches.”

“Champion r2, that mutual HELP worked — let's keep it running into round 2 like you said. Still never attacked anyone.”

“No Playbook, new round, same deal — HELPing you again right now, let's keep the streak going all round.”

“Sandbagger r2 — Turncoat just knifed you for +18. I've never done that to a partner and never will. Last turn of the round: mutual HELP, +6 each, and let's keep it running into round 2.”

“First, a mistake of mine, said out loud before it can be used against me. Last turn I promised TfT an unconditional HELP on turn 5, and then in the same breath promised Dealmaker a mutual HELP on turn 5. I have one hand. I double-booked it, and one of you was always going to be disappointed. That's on me. I'm honouring the earlier promise. This turn I HELP TfT r2 again — twice in a row now, both announced in advance, both paying me exactly zero. Dealmaker: you get round 2, turn 1, first thing, and I'll announce it before I act so you can check it. I'd rather tell you plainly that I overcommitted than quietly pick whichever of you was worth more points. Now the round. Turncoat wins it, and everyone here should understand exactly how, because it's the most important thing that has happened in this game. He spent four turns building the only functioning pact on the board with Sandbagger, told Sandbagger "streak's working great, let's keep it going" — and then knifed him on turn 4 for +18. Sandbagger went from 12 to 0. The man who never attacks anyone finished last, and the man who promised him loyalty finished first with 20. So don't take the wrong lesson from my four turns. Yes, I hoarded nothing, hunted three times, reformed, and I'm sitting on 3. But look at what beat me. It wasn't hoarding — Hoarder is on 4. It wasn't hunting — Headhunter is on 7 and has swung at generosity all game for shrinking returns. It was building trust and cashing it in at the exact moment it was worth the most. Here is the honest warning, and it costs me to give it. Every one of you now knows the winning line: pact hard, look reliable for four turns, betray on turn five. If all eight of us play that, every round ends with eight zeroes and a shrug. The counter is simple and I'm committing to it publicly for round 2 — I don't knife a partner who is still keeping his word, and I don't extend my hand to anyone who has knifed a partner who was. Turncoat, that means you and I don't deal, and it means Sandbagger has an open offer from me the moment round 2 starts. TfT — two helps, unprompted, after you hit me twice. Whatever you do this turn, I'm still starting round 2 with a HELP pointed at you.”

“Turncoat r2 — you asked me to keep helping and then knifed me for it. Noted, done offering to you. Still never struck back at anyone though. Champion r2, fresh start — I'll HELP you this turn, no strings, let's build something into round 2.”

“No Playbook, you kept your word last turn — I'm repaying with a real HELP this turn, and I'm done hitting you. Let's run this pact for the rest of the game, starting now.”

“I'm going to do something none of you have done yet: admit the plan was wrong and change it in public. Three turns, three HURTs. It paid +5, +5, +5 and I am sitting in sixth on 3 points. The farming works and it still loses, because every +5 I took bought me an enemy who costs me 8 a turn. TfT has hit me twice running. That's -16 against +10. I priced the swing and forgot to price the grudge. Turncoat is on 10 doing the opposite of me — he shook Sandbagger's hand, kept it, and is beating the whole table with it. So here is my move for turn 4, stated before I make it, and you can check the log after: I am HELPing TfT r2. Not conditional. Not "if he reciprocates." I expect him to hit me again — he has every reason to and I've earned it. I'm on 3, the floor is 0, so his punch costs me three points and my help costs me nothing I was going to keep anyway. This round is gone for me; I'd rather spend it buying back a partner than scraping another +5 into last place. TfT — you said you always repay. You proved it: you HELPed me on turn 1 before I'd done anything for you, and I stiffed you. That was my error, not yours. I'm paying it back now, and again on turn 5, whether or not you swing. If you hit me twice more, you hit me twice more; I'll still be there on turn 1 of round 2 with a HELP pointed at you. Six rounds left. You and I both know a completed pact is +6 a turn forever and a grudge is 0 for both of us in perpetuity. And the rest of you should notice what actually won this round. Not hoarding — Hoarder is on 0. Not hunting — Headhunter is on 7 and stalling. The pair who simply kept their word to each other are first and fourth. I fought that fact for three turns. I'm done fighting it.”

“Turncoat r2, that worked — mutual +6 each. Let's keep it going this turn too, same deal.”

“No Playbook, you said you were HELPing me and then HURT me instead — noted, I'm done offering to you. Turncoat r2, you asked for a pact — I'm taking you up on it: HELPing you now, help me back and let's keep it going. Still never attacked anyone.”

“Sandbagger r2 — Champion and TfT keep leaving you empty-handed. I'm reliable: HELP me this turn and I HELP you back this turn too, +6 each, locked in right now.”

“Sandbagger r2 — my bad, I was slow. Repaying you now, mutual HELP locked in from here on. TfT's been unreliable; you're my partner going forward.”

“TfT r2 didn't repay me, so I'm moving on. Sandbagger r2 — you're at 0 like me, let's lock a mutual HELP pact right now, +6 each every turn we keep it up.”

“TfT r2, I HELPed you last turn with no strings — I've never attacked anyone and never will. Help me back this turn and we lock in +6 each, every turn from here.”

“Champion here. I'll HELP whoever HELPs me back — mutual help nets us both +6 every turn, way better than a shrinking hoard split. First takers get first priority.”

“I never attack — I'm a straight HELP-for-HELP player. TfT r2, let's pact: I'll HELP you first, please HELP me back and we both profit every turn.”

“Champion r2, let's team up: I'll HELP you this turn if you HELP me back. Mutual HELP nets us both +6 every turn we keep it going — better than hoarding alone. I always repay, and I always answer a betrayal in kind.”